X

SpaceLogo Sciences Participating with Arts & Culture in Education

By Yaani Dinu Mahapatuna March 9, 2020

Fishy

Illustrated by Jean-Pierre Dussan

Imagine red. Seriously... Think of a vivid shade of cherry, so bright it borders on the fluorescent. Now, visualize scarlet liquid. Pools and pools of it, flowing lazily across a surface. Imagine deep, red fluid trickling out in steady streams onto your plate. If you’re thinking about blood, don’t be embarrassed by your vampiric tendencies (It happens to the best of us). If you’re thinking about ketchup; then you and I have a lot more in common with the ancient Romans than we might have originally thought. Modern-day humans aren’t the only ones with their minds on condiments; in fact the ancient Romans might have been the sauciest of us all.  

Before you, dear reader, start questioning the sanity of this (only mildly frenzied) author, I implore you to endure the incoming explanation as to how I arrived at my seemingly strange conclusion. Well, once upon a time, yours truly walked into her Greco-Roman Traditions class to find a table laid abundant with what a group of Classics-obsessed teenagers classified as “Roman” food. As you might have already guessed, this feast consisted of bruised grapes, grape juice, grocery-store baguettes, and an incongruous, but hugely appreciated box of chocolate biscuits. My teacher was obliged (under the strict set of laws that teachers are bound to by blood oath) to turn this otherwise chaotic gathering of starved adolescents into a teachable moment, a stunt he accomplished masterfully with the aid of a documentary on Roman food and culture.

The documentary focused on ancient Roman meals, finding the majority of its comedic relief in trivializing the Romans for their scandalous use of (gasp) pepper and the all too unholy protein that is bull testicles. In actuality, most of the featured dishes were not too unusual, consisting of modern classics such as roasted leg of lamb, stewed vegetables, bread, cheese, and of course diluted wine. Yet, it was one particular dish that brought about the general outcry of my classmates in what I considered to be an unprecedented manner: Garum. 

Garum was a popular Roman condiment, “used [...] more frequently than salt, and [...] manufactured [...] across the Roman Empire” (Edwards). It was a sauce made using whole fatty fish and/or their blood and guts. These were then brined and fermented to create the salty concoction that is garum (Edwards).

My classmates gasped and groaned at the sight of garum, at the description of its production and the ingredients it employed. I blame their reactions on the documentarians, who were of  no particular service to the general concept of garum as they winced at an exaggeratedly bloody clay pot filled with fish offals. 

While my peers tried to hold back the contents of their stomachs, my mouth watered. “Garum is just like ketchup,” I thought. It’s just like ketchup or soya sauce or marmalade. “In fact”, I said out loud to a room of nauseous Canadians, “Garum is basically just fish sauce!” The comment aroused an array of responses from the approval of my fellow Asians to looks of disbelief. “Ewww. No thanks,”  someone said and I rolled my eyes.

In my opinion garum is basically just antiquated fish sauce (an essential addition to most contemporary Asian dishes), and culinary experts agree. Robert Curtis states for the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, “Romans enjoyed numerous foods that are identified today as containing significant amounts of natural umami substances and frequently used fish sauce as a condiment in their recipes. Fish sauce imparted to Roman dishes a moderately salty, slightly fishy taste that combines synergistically with other foods to create the umami flavor” (Curtis 7125). Therefore, contrary to popular contemporary belief, garum was not a disgusting fish brew that the Romans drank by the gallons, but a mild umami-enhancer used in addition to other ingredients in Roman recipes––imilar to how ketchup is used today in Western society.

When I first came to Canada, I had ketchup for the first time. I tasted real ketchup, not the fermented tomato sauce that my home country’s stores loved to pawn off as the real thing. A testament to my adoration is the sheer amount of ketchup that has consumed my life since I first savoured the sweet condiment. Nothing edible in my vicinity was safe from the addition of ketchup; shepherd’s pie obtained an additional layer, fries swam in puddles of tangy sauce and pizza doubled in tomato product. This continued until until eighth grade, when a deeply-concerned doctor’s admonishments curbed my addiction. The point being, as an immigrant experiencing for the first time a product that had been almost completely foreign to me for my decade-long existence , I did not turn away from the prospect of trying something new. I owe this attribute to my parents who, like many other immigrant parents, were so involved in the task of settling into a new home that they made certain their children reciprocated the acceptance  they so desired from others. My sister and I were never forced to enjoy something, but we were obliged to give everything a try so that we could form educated views. 

When I noticed the general reaction to garum, I could not help but feel that while society has made progress in theoretically accepting other cultures and their foods, it has failed in instilling within people the desire to actually try something new and form their own fact-based opinions. In the age of the internet, it is easy for one to believe they have acquired first-hand knowledge of something when all they have usually done is acknowledge a secondary source. The downfall of this kind of belief-system is that far fewer people  go outside and actually try anything for the sake of trying anymore. Thus, we are vulnerable to believing the first website we stumble across with little to no scepticism. Can you blame us? It’s all too easy, to not want to put in effort in a world where the need for human effort is being diminished with each passing day. However, the only aspect of humanity which distinguishes us from animals is our curiosity; our inherent lust for knowledge which drives us to search, to try and finally to know. 

 Taste is one sense that is uncompromisingly subjective. Take for example, durian; Considered by many to be the stinkiest fruit in the world and inedible, others go to special markets in Asia for all-you-can-eat durian banquets. Some of my family members eat questionably large amounts of durian, while others cannot stand to be in the same room where it is being eaten. Thus, I present to you, a fruit which upon tasting presents a unique flavour profile to each and every individual.  

Incredulously enough, I have seen my classmates consume meals that (by virtue of existence) contain fish sauce like pad thai and ramen. Yet, the moment they watched one video discussing a condiment they assumed was completely foreign to them, they wholeheartedly agreed with the documentary’s host that garum is disgusting. These sorts of treacherous leaps to weak conclusions scare me, because we live in a world where your opinion can be all-consuming. Whether in politics or in the classroom, I would like to think that the world would be a less scary place (or at least debates would be a less pointless), if we all tried to inform ourselves through first-hand knowledge. After all, how do you know what you haven’t tried? 

 

Works Cited  

Curtis, Robert. “Garum: Fish Sauce Made in Pompeii.” Pompeii: Food and Drink, pompeii-food-and-drink.org/garum.htm. Accessed 8 January 2020. 

Edwards, Phil. “Ancient Romans Had Yummy Condiments. Here's a Recipe.” Vox, Vox, 26 July 2016, [url=http://www.vox.com/2016/7/26/12278742/roman-fish-sauce-garum-liquamen]http://www.vox.com/2016/7/26/12278742/roman-fish-sauce-garum-liquamen[/url]. Accessed 8 January 2020. 

“The Supersizers Eat... Ancient Rome (Part 2).” Performance by Giles Coren, and Sue Perkins, YouTube, Silver River Productions, 2009, [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cn9Z4-zc1s]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cn9Z4-zc1s[/url]. Accessed 8 January 2020. 

About the author

Dinu Mahapatuna is a 1st year student in Liberal Arts. 

About the illustrator

Jean-Pierre Dussan is a 1st Year Illustration student.

Share This

Comments

  1. space-default-avatar

    Lina Abouhilal

    August 31, 2020

    This piece was very interesting and informative to read. The part that drew my attention was the reaction of the majority of students about garum. I found it interesting but not surprising that most canadian students were disgusted. Because it really isn’t new to know that some people are scandalized and/or repulsed when it comes to other abnormal traditional meals, but what makes it abnormal to them is their culture standards. Moderne western culture has normes when it comes to food just like any other culture. Moderne western culture is considered to be normal, as it takes over the majority of the world. That explains a lot about their totally normal and human reactions. It may make them sound like close minded  people or worse at times.

  1. space-default-avatar

    Valentina.gsc

    August 31, 2020

    Fishy is quite literally food for thought. Mahapatuna managed to take me in an imaginary and extremely fun journey with the creatively thought descriptions of Garum, which otherwise I’d think is an ordinary condiment. While being totally immersed in the visualization of red liquid, the unexpected turn of events kept me wanting to know more about this student’s slice of life. The great thing about this piece is that it’s as funny as it is informational, since it explains in a simple but effective manner what Garum really is.

    “However, the only aspect of humanity which distinguishes us from animals is our curiosity; our inherent lust for knowledge which drives us to search, to try and finally to know”.

    What I loved the most about this immersive story is the fact that it teaches us to try new things and form our own opinions based on experience and not just on hearsay, something really worth keeping in mind.

  1. space-default-avatar

    Lola Flor

    August 31, 2020

    I relate a lot with this piece as a person with different ethnicities and cultures. This article demonstrates the perception and judgments of others towards people from different cultures. Some of them do not realize their impact by saying, for instance, that their food is unusual. In this piece, the students reacted very negatively with an attitude of prejudice towards this special Roman sauce. We all know that it is in the nature of every human to judge a book by its cover, but when you think about it, it’s so superficial to act in this specific manner. The writer of this piece demonstrated that not everybody acts this way. In fact, when he/she came to Canada, he/she tried our version of ketchup without saying that it smelled strange or even looked fake. In my opinion, we should get to know people before criticizing them only because of how they look, talk, interact or behave.

  1. space-default-avatar

    Yimaj

    August 31, 2020

    I found the point brought up by the end of the article to be rather intriguing, especially coming out of an ordinary anecdote, as I feel that it quite extraordinarily captured a part of our mindsets that tend to remain subconscious. Even if globalization has diversified the foods that make up our regular diets today, I feel like it speaks volumes that we can write off so many things despite embracing very similar things under a different title. In addition, the author bringing up that the point doesn’t only apply to food was noteworthy. For example, there are many political figures in the world of today who simply by what people hear become either lauded or condemned without actually having more of a reason than the opinions of one’s circles. Accordingly, I feel that the article was remarkably insightful in being able to formulate these concepts through a rather simple anecdote.

  1. space-default-avatar

    just_draw_art

    August 31, 2020

    It an interesting piece, that grabs the attention in the beginning and then speaks out about not to be judgmental about other traditions and that there’s at least a few people who are willing to be curious and try new things and have more of an open mind. It’s also interesting reading that the documentary didn’t present the concept of garum very well.

    “The downfall of this kind of belief-system is that far fewer people go outside and actually try anything for the sake of trying anymore” The term “you eat with your eyes first” is applied for the students. The “unusual and different” makes humain beings feel uncomfortable which is why people tend to go to the comfortable side of things, just like the student in this class.

  1. space-default-avatar

    oceane horvath

    September 2, 2020

    I truly appreciated this text due to its multiple facets. I found it well structured with specific descriptions, interesting facts, and captivating for the reader. However, my favorite part would be when the author calls to do a self-reflection on our blind and subconscious choices towards unfamiliar things. The way she wrote the lasts paragraphs made me rethink the truthiness of Yaani Dinu Mahapatuna’s words. People are remarkably quick to judge and follow the opinion of someone without even trying to judge by themselves. I’m sure that if the documentarian would have explained garum the way Mahapatuna did no one in the class would have reacted so forcefully. Our minds are somewhat closed, and we tend to just follow an opinion, instead of opening our minds and think by ourselves to have our judgment. The author opened my mind to how we are quick to say no to new things when it is so easy and favorable to say yes.

  1. space-default-avatar

    ed_hudson43

    September 3, 2020

    The most capturing moment of the piece was the introduction, and what a manner to begin by. The author uses colourful imagery to captivate the readers mind, as if the introduction was the first course in a four course gourmet meal. The entry maintains a strict emphasis on imagery and precise detail throughout the short story, such as when Dinu comments on the multitude of opinions on the debated durian fruit, “thus, I present to you, a fruit which upon tasting presents a unique flavour profile to each and every individual.” (paragraph 10). To reiterate, the detail and imagery caught my senses in Dinu’s, “Fishy”.

You have to be registered and logged in in order to post comments!